Does a crack mean the instrument was poorly made?

No. When a string instrument cracks in dry weather, the cause is a lack of moisture in the air, and it says nothing about how well the instrument was made. Cracks are rare, and the best protection is a humidifier set between 40 and 50 percent in the room where the instrument lives.

Every instrument is made by different hands from different trees, and no two trees are alike. Long after it becomes an instrument, the wood keeps taking on moisture and giving it up, expanding in humid weather and shrinking when the heat comes on. A heated Northeast home in January can drop to 10 to 18 percent humidity, far below what the wood wants.

Most of the time the instrument protects itself first, because the hide glue lets a seam open before the wood gives way. A crack is the rarer case, and it should come in right away, because a crack left to spread becomes a much bigger repair. For the full winter routine, see Does winter really damage instruments?